Shop

HTF Retired 1999 TY 10" Plush HOPE Praying Kneeling BEAR (*73)

$ 11 $ 6.6

RARE Vintage w/ ERRORS 1998 TY Beanie Babies Roam Stuffed Toy Plush Buffalo

$ 880 $ 528

Beautiful 10" TY 2012 Retired Chocolate Brown HARLEY Plush DOG (*45)

$ 8.79 $ 5.27

Vintage TY 2000 PERKINS Laying Classic Puppy Dog Brown White Plush w/ tag

$ 18.19 $ 10.91

Retired TY Mango Orangutan Classic Plush 20 inch Brown 1994 Tag Stuffed

$ 30.79 $ 18.47

RARE Ty 2003 Classic Pig-OMELET, 13" Pink Pig Plush

$ 33.88 $ 20.32

TY Beanie Classic Plush - CALHOUN the DOG NWT 2003

$ 15.83 $ 9.49

Ty Classic Baby Paws The Bear Plush Teddy Bear 1996 12" Black Grizzly Bear Brown

$ 4.91 $ 2.95

NWT 2005 TY Plush 10" PRESENTS White DOG Christmas w/ Collar & Stocking (*85)

$ 13.2 $ 7.91

Gorgeous Retired 2002 Ty 14" MOLASSES Dark Brown Plush BEAR w/ Plaid Ribbon (*25

$ 13.19 $ 7.91

1000 Original BTP (brand) Beanie Baby Tag Protectors IN STOCK NOW!

$ 131.99 $ 79.19

Ty Classic Memphis Hound Dog Plush Brown 15" Long Floppy Ears Soft Lay Down 2001

$ 21.97 $ 13.18

Ty Classic Peaches The Himalayan Cat New

$ 26.35 $ 15.81

Ty Classic Lagoon The Blue Bear Retired Mint With Mint Tags

$ 7.92 $ 4.75

Ty Cinders Black Dog Plush 3rd Gen Classic Plush 1994 Korea Puppy 17"

$ 35.19 $ 21.11

Ty Classic 2007 Puppy Dog Bean Plush Stuffed Animal Soft Toy 12” Brown White Tan

$ 76.56 $ 45.93

TY Classic 1997 SAHARA THE LION (With Tag) and SPOUT THE ELEPHANT

$ 11.39 $ 6.83

Vintage TY Classic Black Kitty Cat "COAL" Plush 1996 w/Red Ribbon Retired 15"

$ 11.43 $ 6.85

Ty Classics Boggs Dog Plush Gray Terrier 12 Inch Stuffed Beanie Puppy Curly

$ 11.95 $ 7.17

1997 Ty “BENGAL” Tiger Cub Plush Cat - NWT

$ 9.46 $ 5.67

2006 Ty Classic Boone Puppy Cream Brown Shaggy Soft Dog Plush Stuffed Animal

$ 26.39 $ 15.83

Ty Bunny Rabbit Plush Classic Ty PETER Brown Vtg 1999 Large 15" Stuffed Retired

$ 17.59 $ 10.55

Cute 8" Ty 2016 PIPPIE Plush White & Pink DOG w/ Purple Glitter Eyes (*64)

$ 9.67 $ 5.8

HTF Retired 2005 Ty Buddies 10" VEGGIES Plush Tan BUNNY Rabbit Carrot EASTER

$ 13.19 $ 7.91

Ty rumbles

$ 17.6 $ 10.56

Ty Classic plush Mortimer Moose 1995 beanbag floppy brown 16" tag

$ 7.99 $ 4.79

HTF 10" Retired 1995 4th Gen Ty Classic FAITH White Teddy Bear Plush (*64)

$ 11 $ 6.6

Ty Classic Plush - MERCURY the Silver / Grey Dog (12 Inch)(Stuffed Animal) MWMT

$ 43.91 $ 26.34

Ty Classic "PISTON" Cheetah with spots, 2003 New #07441 cat

$ 26.4 $ 15.83

Ty 11” Classic Cobbler Tabby Kitty Cat Plush Stuffed Toy

$ 48.4 $ 29.04

2001 Ty Classic GODZILLA Plush Figure, Japan Exclusive, 12" Long x 8" High, Mint

$ 36.96 $ 22.17

Ty Classic Nibbles Bunny Rabbit Plush Brown Natural Realist Hare Stuffed Toy

$ 12.32 $ 7.39

Ty Classic Licorice Black Kitty Cat Stuffed Plush 1997 Red Ribbon Bow 15" VTG

$ 17.59 $ 10.55

Ty Classic Scooter Brown Puppy Dog Plush 16" Stuffed Animal 1999 Scruffy Fluffy

$ 61.59 $ 36.95

Ty Classic Plush - SUPERDOG the Dog (12 Inch)(Stuffed Animal) MINT with MINT TAG

$ 43.91 $ 26.34

TY Classic Plush - SAHARA the Lion - MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy

$ 13.1 $ 7.86

Adorable HTF 7" Ty Beanie Boos FANTASIA Tie Dye UNICORN w/ Gold Sparkle 2017

$ 8.79 $ 5.27

Ty Gloss Pinkys Pink Dog Laying Furry 15" Mint With Tag Plush

$ 14.95 $ 8.97

TY Classic Plush "Lagoon" the Bear from 2001 Retired

$ 20.46 $ 12.27

3 TY Classic Plush BENGAL Tiger SAHARA lion CHA CHA monkey 9” Stuffed Animal

$ 13.15 $ 7.89

Ty Classic Beanie Buddy - CHAMP the NY New York Yankees Excl Bear (12 Inch) MWMT

$ 36.86 $ 22.11

ty classic beanie baby plush Black Cat “ Moonstruck” 13” W/ Tag. Stuffed toy

$ 66 $ 39.6

Vintage TY Classic Tango plush white monkey with tags stuffed 1994 11" collectib

$ 13.19 $ 7.91

TY BEAUT Koala Bear Classic from 2003 - 12" MWMTs

$ 20.19 $ 12.11

TY Classic Plush - NUZZLE the Dog (2001 - Ty Silk Version) (11 inch) - MWMTs

$ 55.34 $ 33.2

BNWT TY "BIG GEORGE Gorilla w/TY BABY GEORGE Gorilla 1989 RETIRED (Collectable)!

$ 147.84 $ 88.7

Vintage 1999 TY Classic 14" PURPLEARY Purple & Blue BEAR w/ Bow & Hang Tags (*5)

$ 6.6 $ 3.95

Ty Classic MACDOUGAL Westie White Terrier Dog Plush Stuffed Animal Toy *with tag

$ 9.67 $ 5.8

Cute Retired 2002 Ty 13" WOODY Plush Tan BEAR w/ Ribbon (*2b)

$ 6.15 $ 3.69

Princess Diana TY Beanie Baby, 1st Production Made in China No Space No Stamp

$ 19321.63 $ 11592.97

TY Classic Plush - RESCUE the Dog - MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy

$ 25.25 $ 15.15

TY Beanie Buddy Collection Beani the Gray Long haired Cat 11" w/red bow 2002

$ 17.6 $ 10.56

Ty Classic RAGS Gray Shaggy Puppy Dog Plush Floppy Stuffed Animal 2000 Tags 14in

$ 21.95 $ 13.17

1997 TY Beanie Baby Classic 10" Bengal Tiger Plush Brand New! Perfect Condition!

$ 21.95 $ 13.17

Ty Biscuit Dog Plush Brown Cocker Spaniel 15" Soft Toy 1996 Classic Puppy Rare!

$ 30.75 $ 18.45

Ty Classic Biscuit Dog Plush Brown 3rd Gen 15" Soft Toy 1996 Puppy

$ 21.12 $ 12.67

Ty Classic Plush Golden Lab Retriever Puppy Plush Dog 2009 Silky Soft Goldwyn

$ 23.75 $ 14.25

Ty Classic Lamb Plush Named Sheepers from 2006 (See Description)

$ 13.2 $ 7.91

Ty Classic / Plush "Presto" 2004 Bunny Rabbit 9" of Curly White Blue eyed

$ 4.39 $ 2.63

TY Classic Plush - COTTON the White Bunny (Large Tag - 12 inch)(Near Mint Tag)

$ 17.5 $ 10.5

Ty - Retired - 1999 - "Yesterbear" Classic Ivory Bear Plush - Luminous Fur! NWOT

$ 7.03 $ 4.21

TY BEANIE BUDDY ORIGINAL JAKE MALLARD DUCK 10" M PLUSH STUFFED ANIMAL 1998 NEW

$ 17.16 $ 10.29

TY Classic Plush - YODELER the St. Bernard Dog (PASTEL - 14.5 inch) - MWMTs

$ 37.74 $ 22.64

Ty Classic Toffee Dog Plush Tan Brown 1999 w/ Tag Lovey Large 13" FAST SHIP

$ 41.03 $ 24.62

TY 1994 Plush Large Black Puppy Dog CINDERS Stuffed Animal Toy with TAG 14 IN

$ 19.36 $ 11.61

Rare Retired 2006 Ty Classic Dog STUBBS 14" Stuffed Plush - NWT

$ 17.55 $ 10.53

VGUC-14" 2014 Ty Classic Yodeler St Bernard Dog Plush Stuffed Brown White

$ 17.6 $ 10.56

A67 Ty Classics Tidbit Cream Puppy Dog Plush 11" Stuffed Toy Lovey

$ 26.29 $ 15.77

1995 TY 11" BROWN BEAR PLUSH WITH RED RIBBON ~ RETIRED PVC PELLETS

$ 66 $ 39.6

TY Classic 10" ACE Dalmatian Puppy Dog Plush Stuffed Animal Toy with Tags

$ 35.18 $ 21.1

TY MWMT BARLEY THE DOG CLASSIC- 11"- NEW- SOFT AND SO PRECIOUS!

$ 26.39 $ 15.83

Ty Classic Siberian Husky/Wolf BOOMTOWN MWMTs

$ 17.55 $ 10.53

Ty Classic Dakota Plush Siberian Husky Stuffed Animal Gray White Retired VTG 90s

$ 15.79 $ 9.47

TY CLASSIC YODELER Puppy Dog Rainbow Pastel Plush Fuzzy Glitter Eyes 14” Girl B2

$ 10.56 $ 6.33

Ty Dakota The Husky Wolf Dog Plush Beanie Baby Gray White Blue Eyes w/Tag EUC

$ 14.45 $ 8.67

Vintage Ty Classic Plush "HONEY" the Puppy Dog, 1995, 16", Korea, #2001, MWMT!

$ 22 $ 13.2

NWT 15" Plush TY Classic Frog Bayou 2003 CROAKS Rattle Super Soft Green NEW

$ 12.53 $ 7.51

Ty 1999 Stuffed Plush 16" Light Brown Bear w/ Red Ribbon

$ 8.79 $ 5.27

2006 Buddies 12" TY Beanie Buddy THUNDERBOLT Horse Plush Stuffed Animal

$ 9.7 $ 5.82

BABY AUBURN TY Classic Soft Plush Teddy Bear NWT NEW 13 Inch

$ 15.83 $ 9.49

10 NEW OLD STOCK Beanie Baby Plastic Heart Shaped Tag Protectors Easy Open USA

$ 8.8 $ 5.28

TY Beanie Pink Bear 2002 Glimmer Shimmer Tulip Soft Collectible Retired14"

$ 8.79 $ 5.27

TY Classic Plush RUMBLES the Gorilla NEW Stuffed Animal Toy NWT 10"

$ 7.04 $ 4.22

TY BEANIE BABY RED #1 EMPLOYEE 15" M PLUSH STUFFED ANIMAL 2002 IU HOOSIER NEW

$ 16.67 $ 10

Ty Classic Plush - SANDY the Dog 13" (Stuffed Animal) MINT with NEAR MINT TAG

$ 37.75 $ 22.65

TY Classic Brown Shaggy Dog Baylee 2017 Plush Stuffed Animal Tan Golden

$ 15.84 $ 9.5

Vintage 1990 TY Plush Large  Teddy Bear 16"  Collectible Adorable

$ 22.88 $ 13.72

Ty Angel White Persian Cat Plush 1987 19" Kitty Hairy FAST SHIP stuffed animal

$ 22 $ 13.2

TY WHITE PUPPY

$ 6.15 $ 3.69

Vintage Ty Plush 1991 Brown Shaggy Dog Stuffed Animal Toy 17" Rare Fluffy HTF

$ 43.99 $ 26.39

TY Classic 9" TAFFY Terrier Puppy Dog Plush Stuffed Animal Toy with Tags

$ 14.94 $ 8.96

Ty Classic Kittles Tuxedo Kitty Cat Stuffed Toy Fluffy White Black 2007

$ 17.55 $ 10.53

TY VINTAGE CAT LOT LEOPARD,TABBY CAT AND MAGGIE W TAGS USED ESTATE SELL

$ 79.19 $ 47.51

Moose NEW Korea with HangTag TY Classics 1995 Mortimer 18" Plush

$ 18.65 $ 11.19

Ty Classic Puppy Dog Laces Golden Brown 17" Plush Toy Stuffed Animal Floppy 2004

$ 18.43 $ 11.06

Vintage TY 1987 Plush Lamb, Made in Korea

$ 65.99 $ 39.59

1991 Ty Classic Wally Walrus Plush 12" Tusks Brown Style#7423 Stuffed Rare

$ 26.39 $ 15.83

TY Classic Plush - ORCHARD the Bunny (10 inch) - MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy

$ 28.94 $ 17.36

Ty Classic Plush - TANGY the Cat (12 Inch)(Stuffed Animal) MINT with MINT TAG

$ 70.31 $ 42.18

TY Classic Pepper Puppy Dog 1996 Plush Brown Black Vintage Stuffed Animal 10"

$ 13.81 $ 8.28